Modern Mattress vs Casper. Which is right for you?
Try-before-you-buy in 6 Saskatchewan stores, or order Casper online.
Same trial. Same warranty. Different brand DNA.
Same trial, same warranty. The difference is the free 30-minute Discovery Experience. Beyond that it comes down to who owns the brand, where it ships from, and whether you can lie on it before you buy.
Saskatchewan-rooted. Try first.
- 6 Saskatchewan stores to lie on every collection
- Nine collections on the floor, starting from $397
- Free front-door delivery in our store cities; in-home setup $59; VIP setup + old-mattress removal $99
- 100 Night Sleep Guarantee · one in-store comfort exchange, $99 fee
- Warranty up to 10 years (Modern 9″ is 5), handled by a local team
- Discovery Experience: body-mapped fitting + printout
- Independently owned, founded in Yorkton, 2014
- Designed in Saskatchewan, made in Canada
US-origin DTC brand. Online ordering.
- Online ordering through casper.ca · very limited Canadian retail
- Multiple models (Original Foam, Hybrid, Wave, Nova)
- Free shipping in Canada (mattress arrives in a box)
- 100-night sleep trial
- 10-year warranty
- No in-person consultation in Canada
- US-headquartered (Casper Sleep Inc., New York)
Where each one wins.
| Feature | Modern Mattress | Casper Canada |
|---|---|---|
| Try in person in Canada | 6 SK stores, full lineup on floor | Very limited Canadian retail |
| Mattress options | A full mattress lineup (Modern, Emma, Studio, Classic, Luna, Signature, Natural, Hybrid Luxe, Artisan) | 4 main models (Original, Hybrid, Wave, Nova) |
| Trial period | 100 nights | 100 nights |
| Warranty | Up to 10 years | 10 years |
| Delivery | Free front-door delivery in our store cities; in-home setup $59; VIP setup + old-mattress removal $99 | Courier-dropped at your door |
| Returns / exchange | 100-night guarantee · one in-store swap, $99 | Pickup coordinated with customer service |
| Sleep consultation | Discovery Experience: body-mapping | Self-serve online |
| Brand origin | Saskatchewan-founded, Canadian-owned | US-headquartered, sells in Canada via casper.ca |
| Made in Canada | Designed in SK, made in Canada | Production varies by model |
| Adjustable base options | Essential and Plus bundled | Sold separately |
Who each one is built for.
Both are well-known mattresses. They serve different shoppers.
Choose Modern Mattress if you...
- Want to lie on the mattress before you buy
- Live in or near Saskatoon, Regina, Moose Jaw, or Yorkton
- Have specific sleep issues and want a fitting
- Want white-glove delivery and setup in your bedroom
- Prefer to handle warranty in person at a local store
- Want to support an independent, Canadian-owned brand
- Want more options across more price points (a full lineup vs 4 models)
- Want an adjustable-base bundle
Choose Casper Canada if you...
- Live nowhere near a mattress retailer and prefer online shopping
- Want a recognizable US-origin brand
- Are comfortable arranging your own delivery setup
- Have already decided on your preferred model
- Don’t mind shipping logistics if returning
- Don’t need an adjustable base bundled
Common questions, straight answers.
Is Casper better than Modern Mattress?
Neither is universally better. Both run a 100-night program and long-term warranty coverage (ours runs up to 10 years by collection, with the Modern 9-inch line at 5). Modern Mattress wins on try-before-buy (6 Saskatchewan stores vs Casper's online-only Canadian operation), white-glove delivery and setup, a larger lineup with nine collections on the floor, and being independently owned and Canadian-made. Casper has a longer market track record and a recognizable US-origin brand.
Can I try Casper before buying in Canada?
Casper has very limited physical retail in Canada. Most Casper mattresses are sold online via casper.ca and shipped in a box. Modern Mattress has 6 Saskatchewan stores where every collection is on the floor.
Where is Casper based?
Casper is a US-headquartered DTC brand (Casper Sleep Inc., based in New York). Casper sells in Canada through casper.ca. Modern Mattress is a Saskatchewan-founded, independently-owned brand: designed in Saskatchewan, made in Canada, sold through six Saskatchewan stores.
What’s the price difference between Modern Mattress and Casper?
Our Queen prices run from $597 on the Modern collection up to the Artisan at the top of the range. Every live price sits on its own product page. Casper’s entry models generally price near our mid-tier, and their premium models sit higher; prices move on both sides, so check both before you decide.
What if I don’t like the mattress after buying?
Modern Mattress: the 100 Night Sleep Guarantee. Sleep on it for up to 100 nights; if the feel isn’t right, come back in and we’ll reselect together: one in-store comfort exchange per purchase, with a $99 exchange fee. Pay the difference if your new pick costs more, or get the difference back if it costs less. It’s an exchange program, not a refund policy (full details). Casper: 100-night trial with pickup return and a refund. Same trial length, different logistics.
Does Casper ship to Saskatchewan?
Yes. Casper Canada ships across the country including Saskatchewan. There’s no physical Casper retail in the province. If you’d rather try mattresses in person before buying, Modern Mattress has 6 Saskatchewan stores.
Is Modern Mattress Canadian-owned?
Yes. Modern Mattress is independently owned and was founded in Yorkton, Saskatchewan in 2014. Mattresses are designed in Saskatchewan and built in Canada. Casper is a US-headquartered brand operating in Canada through casper.ca.
Find your nearest Modern Mattress.
6 stores. 4 cities. Same Canadian-made mattress lineup, same 100 Night Sleep Guarantee, same free front-door delivery within city limits.
The fastest way to know which fits.
The Discovery Experience is free, takes about 30 minutes, and ends with a printout of your pressure points and the collections that fit you. Compare options in one room. No box to unbox. No pickup to schedule.
