Modern Mattress vs Casper. Which is right for you?
Try-before-you-buy in 6 Saskatchewan stores, or order Casper online.
Same trial. Same warranty. Different brand DNA.
Both have a 100-night trial and a 10-year warranty. The differences are who owns the brand, where it ships from, and whether you can lie on it before you buy.
Saskatchewan-rooted. Try first.
- 6 Saskatchewan stores to lie on every collection
- 8 collections from $449 to $4,299
- Free Local Front Door Delivery and white-glove setup
- 100-night sleep guarantee with in-store swap
- 10-year warranty handled by a local team
- Discovery Experience: pressure-mapped fitting + printout
- Independently owned, founded in Yorkton, 2014
- Designed in Saskatchewan, made in Canada
US-origin DTC brand. Online ordering.
- Online ordering through casper.ca — very limited Canadian retail
- Multiple models (Original Foam, Hybrid, Wave, Nova)
- Free shipping in Canada (mattress arrives in a box)
- 100-night sleep trial
- 10-year warranty
- No in-person consultation in Canada
- US-headquartered (Casper Sleep Inc., New York)
Where each one wins.
| Feature | Modern Mattress | Casper Canada |
|---|---|---|
| Try in person in Canada | 6 SK stores, full lineup on floor | Very limited Canadian retail |
| Mattress options | 8 collections (Modern, Aria, Classic, Prestige, Signature, Natural, Hybrid Luxe, Artisan) | 4 main models (Original, Hybrid, Wave, Nova) |
| Trial period | 100 nights | 100 nights |
| Warranty | 10 years | 10 years |
| Delivery | Free Local Front Door Delivery + setup | Courier-dropped at your door |
| Returns / exchange | In-store swap at 6 SK locations | Pickup coordinated with customer service |
| Sleep consultation | Discovery Experience: pressure-mapping | Self-serve online |
| Brand origin | Saskatchewan-founded, Canadian-owned | US-headquartered, sells in Canada via casper.ca |
| Made in Canada | Designed in SK, made in Canada | Production varies by model |
| Adjustable base options | Essential and Plus bundled | Sold separately |
Who each one is built for.
Both are well-known mattresses. They serve different shoppers.
Choose Modern Mattress if you...
- Want to lie on the mattress before you buy
- Live in or near Saskatoon, Regina, Moose Jaw, or Yorkton
- Have specific sleep issues and want a fitting
- Want white-glove delivery and setup in your bedroom
- Prefer to handle warranty in person at a local store
- Want to support an independent, Canadian-owned brand
- Want more options across more price points (8 collections vs 4)
- Want an adjustable-base bundle
Choose Casper Canada if you...
- Live nowhere near a mattress retailer and prefer online shopping
- Want a recognizable US-origin brand
- Are comfortable arranging your own delivery setup
- Have already decided on your preferred model
- Don’t mind shipping logistics if returning
- Don’t need an adjustable base bundled
Common questions, straight answers.
Is Casper better than Modern Mattress?
Neither is universally better. Both have a 100-night trial and 10-year warranty. Modern Mattress wins on try-before-buy (6 Saskatchewan stores vs Casper's online-only Canadian operation), white-glove delivery and setup, larger collection lineup (8 vs 4), and being independently owned and Canadian-made. Casper has a longer market track record and a recognizable US-origin brand.
Can I try Casper before buying in Canada?
Casper has very limited physical retail in Canada. Most Casper mattresses are sold online via casper.ca and shipped in a box. Modern Mattress has 6 Saskatchewan stores where every one of 8 collections is on the floor.
Where is Casper based?
Casper is a US-headquartered DTC brand (Casper Sleep Inc., based in New York). Casper sells in Canada through casper.ca. Modern Mattress is a Saskatchewan-founded, independently-owned brand — designed in Saskatchewan, made in Canada, sold through six Saskatchewan stores.
What’s the price difference between Modern Mattress and Casper?
Modern Mattress collections start at $599 Queen and go up to $3,799 Queen. Casper’s Original is around $995 Queen, Hybrid around $1,495 Queen, Wave/Nova premium models often $2,400+. Modern Mattress is generally competitive or lower at every price tier.
What if I don’t like the mattress after buying?
Modern Mattress: 100-night sleep guarantee. Walk into any of 6 Saskatchewan stores and we’ll work with you to swap to a different feel in person. Casper: 100-night trial with pickup return. Same trial length, different return logistics.
Does Casper ship to Saskatchewan?
Yes — Casper Canada ships across the country including Saskatchewan. There’s no physical Casper retail in the province. If you’d rather try mattresses in person before buying, Modern Mattress has 6 Saskatchewan stores.
Is Modern Mattress Canadian-owned?
Yes. Modern Mattress is independently owned and was founded in Yorkton, Saskatchewan in 2014. Mattresses are designed in Saskatchewan and built in Canada. Casper is a US-headquartered brand operating in Canada through casper.ca.
Find your nearest Modern Mattress.
6 stores. 4 cities. Same Canadian-made mattress lineup, same 100-night guarantee, same Free Local Front Door Delivery.
The fastest way to know which fits.
The Discovery Experience is free, takes about 30 minutes, and ends with a printout of your pressure points and the collections that fit you. Compare options in one room. No box to unbox. No pickup to schedule.